精东传媒

August 30, 2017

Can our cities’ thriving creative precincts be saved from ‘renewal’?

At first glance, old industrial sites, like the one in Carrington Street, Marrickville, don’t look like much. But they provide vital spaces for creative precincts to flourish.

 

 

Governments are busily rezoning our cities for high-rise apartments. The New South Wales government, for example, plans to rezone a 20-kilometre corridor in Sydney, , for urban density, in concert with a new metro rail line. have reacted vociferously to the prospects of high-rise buildings in previously low-density suburbs.

But there is another, overlooked dimension to the redevelopment. Much of it is on industrial land: pockets of old factories and workshops, portrayed as decrepit and in need of renewal.

Our documents enterprises that actually use urban industrial lands. It鈥檚 a story of surprising and largely hidden vibrancy at the interface between creative industries and small manufacturing.

---

Further reading:

---

Planners and economic developers tend to assume manufacturing has left central cities and that manufacturing enterprises can simply locate to city-fringe greenfield sites. In reality, manufacturing is changing form, and often depends on 鈥� and benefits from 鈥� urban industrial lands.

Despite the scale of renewal plans, no detailed knowledge exists of what will be lost, or of existing enterprises鈥� needs.

Manufacturing has a new, creative face

In for renewal strategies, industrial zones are seen as redundant because it鈥檚 assumed that manufacturing is in a state of inevitable decline. This is false and misleading.

Employment, exports, and all point to manufacturing鈥檚 endurance, as well as its transformation and increasingly diverse character.

Most manufacturers these days are small, agile and creative. Manufacturing is increasingly interwoven with creative industries, through innovation-driven additive manufacturing, craft-based production, and bespoke maker scenes.

Cities such as and are actively planning for this, because they recognise that the creative-manufacturing interface generates jobs, assists place marketing, contributes to liveability and enlivens local communities.

 

 

---

Further reading:

---

Creative-manufacturing favours older industrial sites

There is, however, a planning dilemma cities must face. Enterprises at the interface tend to locate in inner-city industrial zones. This is where other relevant enterprises are co-located and buildings are more suitable, often older and lower rent, with limited restrictions on noise.

Like-minded micro-enterprises sub-let workshops or pods within older factory complexes. They cannot afford commercial rents in stand-alone buildings. Older industrial zones also provide access to distribution and business networks, cultural venues and institutions, and final markets.

 

 

These are the very zones favoured for major 鈥渞enewal鈥� schemes. In practically every case, this means medium- and high-rise apartments. Retail space is provided, typically at ground-floor level (which often sits vacant for months or years).

Ironically, the presence of creative industries . But such renewal schemes rarely, if ever, provide replacement workshop space zoned for industrial uses.

Carrington Rd, an unassuming creative-manufacturing hub

Our documents enterprises in one such industrial precinct in Marrickville, inner Sydney, that鈥檚 slated for redevelopment. A single 700-metre-long stretch of Carrington Road is home to more than 200 diverse micro-enterprises and small manufacturers.

These have strong local ties, employing an estimated 1,800 workers. Fifteen discrete enterprise clusters thrive there. These include theatre production, puppet and prop-making, furniture restoration, fashion and textiles.

 

 

What underpins this pre-eminent creative-manufacturing interface precinct? It鈥檚 a combination of affordability, sympathetic landlords, industrial land use zoning, and a mix of small and large factory spaces with suitable features.

Proximity to the CBD, media corporations, major entertainment venues and iconic cultural institutions is vital. That鈥檚 because these firms supply stage sets, install event equipment, rent studios for photography, television and film shoots, and perform at corporate functions.

The social and cultural milieu of surrounding areas is also crucial. These areas generate nearby markets for locally made fashion, jewellery and ceramics.

No consultation on a looming loss for the city

Shockingly, enterprises in industrial zones potentially affected by this latest renewal strategy are not being consulted before rezoning.

NSW Planning and Environment commissioned a consultancy firm to of proposed redevelopments throughout the Sydenham-Bankstown corridor. The report was a desktop study. Detailed site inspections 鈥渨ere not undertaken nor interviews or consultation with businesses in the Opportunity Sites鈥�.

When we visited Marrickville鈥檚 creative-manufacturing enterprises, it became clear none had been consulted about the details of renewal plans for the precinct. They were unaware the closing date for public submissions was imminent.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Creative micro-enterprises and small manufacturers reported that city fringe relocation is not feasible. Rezoning this industrial space, one of inner Sydney鈥檚 last, may force enterprises to close altogether. Others said they would move overseas.

The loss for Sydney could be tragic. As one artisan said:

If all the people who worked on this street worked in one company and were sacked, it鈥檇 be national headlines.

Similar processes are under way in Melbourne鈥檚 inner north, an iconic part of that city鈥檚 cultural profile. Rezoning in the name of urban density has given a green light to the conversion of old light industrial buildings into residential developments.

So, just as Creative Victoria establishes a to host creative practitioners, tenants next door have been evicted to make way for a 12-storey apartment block. The developer has now objected to the potential noise from local venues.

Learning from other global cities

Our project鈥檚 next phase is to explore how other global cities foster creative and manufacturing enterprises.

Chicago has and Portland, Oregon, has . These are long-standing and successful examples of industrial land preservation. The has also long mixed 鈥渘on-disturbing鈥� industry with other uses.

San Francisco鈥檚 attempts to accommodate the growth of small manufacturers. New, higher-rent office development cross-subsidises lower-rent industrial space. Austin, Boston, Los Angeles and Nashville in the US and Vancouver, Canada, are pursuing similar policies.

In China, , the 21st-century 鈥渨orkshop of the world鈥�, is looking to the 鈥渃reative economy鈥� not to replace but to enhance Chinese manufacturing prowess.

While growing cities like Sydney clearly need to plan for housing, another conversation in our cities is needed, not just about high-rise redevelopments, but about what鈥檚 at stake when industrial lands are rezoned.

, Director, UOW Global Challenges Program & Professor of Human Geography, ; , Lecturer, Interdisciplinary Design Studies, ; , Senior Lecturer, Urban and Regional Planning, ; , Research Assistant, Australian Centre for Cultural Environmental Research, ; , Professor of Communications and Cultural Economy, , and , Lecturer in Communications and Media,

This article was originally published on . Read the .

UOW academics exercise academic freedom by providing expert commentary, opinion and analysis on a range of ongoing social issues and current affairs. This expert commentary reflects the views of those individual academics and does not necessarily reflect the views or policy positions of the 精东传媒 of 精东传媒.